In 2005 Wikipedia's first sentence called it “author best known for her controversial book”. Today it says “american journalist and broadcaster”.
Measured, not asserted. Every count, date and revision on this page was taken from Wikipedia's own history and checked against the live article. The words quoted are theirs.
Machine-checked against the full current article on 2026-08-02. In 2005 Wikipedia's first sentence called it “author best known for her controversial book”. Today it says “american journalist and broadcaster”.
We saved snapshots of this article over twenty years; you are reading the 2005 one. Red dashes: removed from Wikipedia since.Pale dots: rewritten; the numbered note shows what it says now.Red text: written in or rewritten since the previous snapshot.1 tap a number or a side note to jump between them
The opening as it read in 2005
Joan Peters is an author best known for her controversial book, From Time Immemorial , published in 1985 .1In Addition to writing books, she has also written for magazines such as Harper's , Commentary , The New Republic , and The New Leader .2She also has produced TV news documentaries regarding the Middle East, acted as a foreign affairs commentator for PBS . Most of her work centers around Middle East affairs, especially the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. During the Carter administration she served as White House Adviser on American Foreign Policy in the Middle East.3
This is Wikipedia's own text, saved in our repository. Their copy of it is revision 16300019.
The opening as it stood in 2010 4 passages from the previous snapshot no longer appear
Joan Peters (born 1938) is a former CBS news producer of otherwise unnamed documentaries, and the author best known for a number of theses on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict , put forward in her book From Time Immemorial , published in 1984.Peters has also written for magazines such as Harper's , Commentary , The New Republic , and The New Leader in the 1970s and early 1980s and has helped create a series of TV news documentaries for CBS in 1973 regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and provided commentary on the subject for PBS .During the Carter administration Peters served in the government as lecturer on issues related to the Middle East to State Department officials.She is currently a trustee for the National Committee on American Foreign Policy , where she serves on its executive committee.
Red text was written in or rewritten since the previous snapshot. Their copy is revision 369798386.
The opening as it stood in 2015 2 passages from the previous snapshot no longer appear
Joan Peters (née Friedman ; April 29, 1936 – January 5, 2015), the family name from an earlier marriage used by Joan Caro, was an author, best known for a number of theses on the Israeli–Palestinian conflict , put forward in her controversial book From Time Immemorial , published in 1984, in which she argued that the Palestinians, as opposed to the Jews, are largely not indigenous to the area and therefore do not have a claim to the territory.The book was argued to be a fraud, later on, by Norman Finkelstein .Finkelstein's position was supported by a number of other scholars, such as Noam Chomsky , Edward Said and Yehoshua Porath , calling the book "ludicrous", "worthless" and a "forgery", while other scholars such as Barbara W.Tuchman and Daniel Pipes accepted the book's central thesis.Peters wrote in the 1970s and early 1980s for magazines such as Harper's , Commentary , The New Republic , and The New Leader , and was a consultant in the creation of TV news documentaries for CBS in 1973 regarding the Israeli–Palestinian conflict and provided commentary on the subject for PBS .Her dedication to the cause of Israel may have been triggered by a visit in the 1970s to the Soviet Union, where officials treated her and her husband with suspicion.According to a speaker's agency that booked speaking and touring engagements for her, Peters served as White House Adviser on American Foreign Policy in the Middle East during the Carter administration .She died at her home in Chicago in 2015 of a cerebral embolism .Shortly before her death, the Israeli ambassador to the United Nations, Ron Prosor , called her to pass on that Israel's prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu was deeply grateful for her important contribution to the Jewish people and the state of Israel." "The Fate of an Honest Intellectual" ".
Red text was written in or rewritten since the previous snapshot. Their copy is revision 668017385.
The opening as it stood in 2020 9 passages from the previous snapshot no longer appear
Joan Peters (née Friedman ; April 29, 1936 – January 5, 2015), later Caro , was the author of the best-selling, controversial, 1984 book From Time Immemorial , in which she argued that Palestinians are largely not indigenous to modern Israel and therefore do not have a claim to its territory.The book was criticized by some scholars such as Norman Finkelstein , Noam Chomsky , Edward Said and Yehoshua Porath .Joan Caro, author of controversial 'From Time Immemorial,' dies at 78 , Haaretz , 8 January 2015. " "The Fate of an Honest Intellectual" ".
Red text was written in or rewritten since the previous snapshot. Their copy is revision 951838656.
The opening as it stood on October 6, 2023 4 passages from the previous snapshot no longer appear
Anerican journalist Joan Peters (née Friedman ; April 29, 1936 – January 5, 2015), later Caro , was an American journalist and broadcaster.She wrote the 1984 book From Time Immemorial , a controversial account of the origins of the Palestinians.
Red text was written in or rewritten since the previous snapshot. Their copy is revision 1168371693.
The opening as it stood in 2025
American journalist (1936–2015) For the American dancer, choreographer, and educator, see Joan Peters (dancer) . Joan Peters (née Friedman ; April 29, 1936 – January 5, 2015), later Caro , was an American journalist and broadcaster. She wrote the 1984 book From Time Immemorial , a controversial book that incorrectly claimed that modern Palestinians were not indigenous to Palestine.
Red text was written in or rewritten since the previous snapshot. Their copy is revision 1282821621. This is our newest snapshot; the live article may have moved again since.
Today
In 2005 Wikipedia's first sentence called it “author best known for her controversial book”. Today it says “american journalist and broadcaster”. Read the current article and compare.
2005
2010
2015
2020
Oct '23
2025
Counts in the opening at each snapshot. Green: the word gained ground. Red: it was cut. Grey: no change.
What Wikipedia says this is
Every article opens by defining its subject. This one was redefined between 2005 and 2025.
Then
author best known for her controversial book
Now
american journalist and broadcaster
Struck red text is no longer in the article; dotted amber text was rewritten. Every revision id links to Wikipedia's copy; the text shown is our own saved copy. Data: /data. Wikipedia text is CC BY-SA; quoted for the record; not affiliated with Wikipedia.